On 12 December 2024, the third edition of the annual workshop of the Cluster Hub “Production of Raw Materials for Batteries from European Resources” took place in Brussels, being co-organised by EU-funded projects RHINOCEROS, CRM-geothermal and CICERO. This third edition, along with an increasing number membership, confirm the hub’s role as a dynamic ecosystem that continues to generate innovations in the European battery materials sector.

The hub’s annual workshop, held as a satellite event of the Raw Materials Week 2024, provided once again a platform for presenting the most promising results from participating projects. Two technical sessions covered the entire battery value chain, from raw materials mining to recycling, while the opening conveniently portrayed the policy, the regulatory and strategic frameworks that support and drive the EU R&I initiatives in the battery sector.

Policy perspectives and supporting mechanisms for the battery sector

Susana Xara, Project adviser on raw materials at European Health and Digital Executive Agency (HaDEA), established the discussions tone, navigating through the insights of the Critical Raw Materials Act [CRMA] and the Net Zero Industry Act [NZIA] and focusing on their contribution to securing a sustainable supply of critical raw materials for the European battery industry.

Download the opening keynote

Wouter IJzermans, BEPA Executive Director, presented the long-term vision and potential revisions of their roadmap, emphasising the importance of policy frameworks and incentives in promoting battery innovation and deployment across Europe.

Download BEPA presentation

The presentation of Vasileios Rizos from the Centre for European Policy Studies (CEPS) identified various barriers and challenges emerging from the EU policy framework on batteries, based on inputs from 20 companies across the entire battery value chain, including partners from the BATRAW project, member of the Cluster Hub since 2022. The representative of CEPS concluded with a set of policy messages referring to early dialogue channels established between policy-makers and various stakeholders. Before the legal requirements entry into force, this information exchange on availability of secondary data sets could enable stakeholders to assess the data quality, select suitable sets of information and identify potential data gaps.

Publicly available resources submitted by CEPS:

• Barriers and policy challenges in developing circularity approaches in the EU battery sector: an assessment – CEPS
• Implementing the EU digital battery passport – CEPS
• Compliance with the EU’s carbon footprint requirements for electric vehicle batteries – CEPS

Download CEPS presentation

Orchestrating the launch and on-going work of the Cluster Hub, PNO Innovation Belgium [part of PNO Group – leader in innovation and funding consultancy], represented by Dr. Nader Akil, concluded the first session with an overview of all EU funding programmes supporting research, innovation and investment in raw materials production for batteries. Additional to the upcoming funding opportunities and guidance on selecting the appropriate funding opportunities based on the status of technology, Dr. Nader Akil introduced another initiative launched by PNO Group – DIAMONDS4IF. This project supports the preparation of Innovation Fund applications, enabling the transfer of H2020 research results into successful ventures and securing investment funding.

Download Funding Schemes presentation

The third session of presentations commenced with an outline of the main findings of the LIFE DRONE project, which concluded in June 2024. Presented by Lorenzo Toro, process engineer at Eco Recycling, the project demonstrated the feasibility of producing high-quality NMC oxide and graphite from recycled batteries. The innovative process confirmed significant environmental benefits, with a reduction of 59 % in terms of kg CO₂ eq. Additionally, one plant is estimated to treat 500 tonnes of batteries/year. The technical-economic evaluation of this industrial plant, with a potential capacity of 500 tons/year, showed a return on investment (ROI) of 31.64 % and a payback time (PBT) of 3.16 years. The analysis indicated that attractive payback times could be obtained even with varying prices for NMC and graphite.

Download LIFE DRONE presentation

RHINOCEROS presenting results of the Electrochemical Li recovery strategy from LIBs black mass

The electrochemical Li recovery from Li-ion battery black mass, investigated in the RHINOCEROS project and presented by Prof. Pier Giorgio Schiavi from Univ. of Sapienza reported Li extraction yields from end-of-life (EoL) LIBs in the range of 82 %, and faradaic efficiency compared to commercial cathode materials (close to 100 %). Researchers have investigated potential causes that could explain the relatively low selectivity ranges of Li and other metals available in black mass. The simultaneous oxidation of impurities found in the black mass can be a justified explanation for the preliminary results obtained. Experimental results show that the extraction percentages for Co, Ni, and Mn remain in very low ranges. When contemplating upscaling scenarios, Prof. Schiavi mentioned the researchers are evaluating an alternative approach that enables the treatment of larger quantities of powder without replicating the manufacturing process of LIB electrodes.

Download RHINOCEROS presentation

The session featured also presentations of other initiatives addressing the batteries recycling topic: Benjamin P. Wilson, Senior Scientist, Hydrometallurgy and Corrosion at Aalto University on behalf of the RESPECT project, Miguel Aguilar, researcher at LEITAT Technological Centre for the BATRAW projects, and Joana Gouveia [Researcher at the Institute of Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Management (INEGI) and America Quinteros [Researcher at LUT Univ.] for the ReLiEF initiative.

Read the entire article

There is an undeclared competition for better, more efficient batteries which pushes researchers to continue developing new methods for extracting and synthesising electrodic materials.

Recovery of lithium as battery grade material

Lithium (Li) is a key component in batteries and scientists involved in the RHINOCEROS Project have been exploring ways to extract it from recycled materials from used batteries known as “black mass” (BM). But one of the challenges scientists are facing is the reduction of fluoride content in extracted Li. Researchers at KIT tested their mechanochemical process for extracting Li from various BM samples provided by partners ACC and TES. Their experiments engaging reactive milling coupled with various reactive agents aimed to reduce the fluoride content of the aqueous solution. These tests showed that using magnesium as a reactive agent yielded most promising results for Li extraction.

Progress in Lithium-Manganese battery materials and Advancements in reduced graphene oxide production

Research team at Sapienza Univ. of Rome (UoS) has been making progress in developing lithium-manganese-rich materials for battery applications. These materials were produced using an integrated hydrometallurgical process, which includes the production of reduced graphene oxide and a co-precipitation method that leads to the formation of lithium-manganese-rich cathodes. The resulting cathode materials are currently undergoing extensive physicochemical and electrochemical characterizations.

For the synthesis of reduced graphene oxide, the researchers compared two methodologies and observed differences in productivity. These differences are now being investigated to determine whether they are influenced by the thermal pre-treatment of the graphite or by the role of metals present in different oxidation states. The use of mechano-chemically treated powder has demonstrated remarkable productivity, reaching approximately 80%.

Enhanced solvometallurgical processes

As evoked by its name, solvometallurgy uses solvents to extract metals. Researchers at TEC have been optimising the process, using additives as copper (Cu) or hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) when necessary, achieving a high recovery rate of >95%. However, the process also increased the dissolved Cu content, which required additional steps to reduce it. Researchers are now exploring methods like cementation or electrodeposition to recover and reuse the dissolved Cu. The deep eutectic solvents (DES) were already regenerated and reused, result which could bring a positive impact on the process sustainability assessment.

Direct recovery of battery materials

The Gas-Diffusion Electrocrystallisation (GDEx) technology allows the one-step recovery of metals and synthesis of new materials with high added value. In the framework of the RHINOCEROS project, the research team at VITO has been focusing on optimising the GDEx technology to achieve the selective recovery of nickel (Ni), manganese (Mn), and cobalt (Co), contained in leachates from black mass and achieved 90 % extraction of Ni, Mn and Co. This two-step GDEx process facilitated the removal of all the impurities such as Cu, Fe from the leachate solution. Using the GDEx process, VITO researchers have successfully synthesised Layered Double Hydroxide (LDH) materials and spinel-type nanostructures from the synthetic solutions. The LDH materials were lithiated and LiNi_0.8Mn_0.1Co_0.1O₂ (LNMCO811) was synthesised, which could be used as a cathode active material for lithium-ion batteries (LiBs).  The results obtained with synthetic solutions portray the potential of the method to obtain relevant active cathode materials out of leachate solutions.

Recovery of materials from low concentration waste streams

Aiming towards a zero-waste strategy for the recovery of metals from battery refining waste waters, LEITAT is working on the development and evaluation of novel polymer inclusion membranes (PIM). PIMs are a type of liquid membrane in which the liquid phase, the extractant, is held within a polymeric network. The interest in these membranes has been growing exponentially over the past few years as an alternative separation technique to conventional solvent extraction.

During the previous six months, the team at LEITAT have been investigating two types of membranes that have shown high selectivity, recovering manganese (Mn) and cobalt (Co) from mixed metal solutions. In their future research, LEITAT will use these membranes in combination to ensure increased selectivity of targeted metals.

Optimising lithium carbonate recovery

Lithium carbonate(Li₂CO₃) is another critical material for batteries, and researchers at TEC and LEITAT are working to optimise its recovery from various solutions. This involves fine-tuning the conditions for Li₂CO₃ precipitation, including the influence of pH and the presence of other cations. Tests are currently conducted with both synthetic solutions and real leachates to ensure the effectiveness of the process. Additionally, efforts are underway to automate the recovery process, which includes assembling elements for pH monitoring and CO₂ bubbling systems.

Bringing innovations to market

To bring these innovations to market, researchers are preparing to scale up their processes. This involves a selective process based on data collection, life cycle assessment (LCA) and life cycle cost (LCC) analysis, to ensure the best technological routes are chosen to be further upscaled and meet the production demands.

Author: KIT

During the third semester, researchers from KIT further studied and improved the conditions for the mechanochemical transformation of black mass (BM) into metallic black mass (MBM). Since BM supplied by ACC is already in a reduced state, they focused on reducing BM supplied by TES. This BM consists mostly of NMC (lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxides) cathode material and graphite, which was found to slow down the reaction kinetics. The reduction of the cathode active material by the metallic reducing agent result in the formation of the transition metals along with lithium oxide (Li₂O) and the oxide of the respective reducing agent, which can be monitored by X-ray diffraction.

In contrast to the previous two semesters, researchers switched from shaker mills to planetary mills, which enable control of the rotation speed and larger volumes that can be processed. Various parameters such as ball-to-sample ratio (BSR), ball size, total load and rotation speed were investigated to optimise for a short reaction time.

Main take-aways

In general, the higher the BSR, the more mechanical energy can be transferred per gram of powder which results in a more intense milling and a faster reaction; however, this limits the throughput. Larger balls, on the one hand, lead to higher kinetic energies. On the other hand, fewer balls are used to keep the BSR constant resulting in a lower collision frequency. The maximum rotation speed is lower to prevent damage to the grinding media.

With Calcium as the reducing agent, no reaction was achieved at all. An unfavorable combination of ductility and size of the calcium pieces seems to resist further size reduction, which is required for the reaction.

Aluminium has the advantage of being used as a current collector and is already present in the black mass. However, during the reaction, LiAlO₂ is formed, which is limiting the subsequent Li extraction efficiency in WP5. This problem can be avoided when magnesium is used as the reducing agent, which proved to be more reactive than aluminium but doesn’t form other lithium compounds than Li₂O.

Compared to the shaker mill, a higher reaction rate was observed in the planetary mill. Researcher from KIT achieved a complete conversion of the lithium transition metal oxide in the planetary mill within 3 h using Mg as the reducing agent. In a larger version of the mill, the required milling time increases to 8 hours. Here, further investigations are planned for the next months.

Read previous article on the pre-treatment operations: Pre-treatment operations: Reactive milling for the production of metallic black mass

© Photo: Adobe

Author: KIT

Following previous work performed in work package 5, researchers from KIT further investigated the lithium (Li) extraction from black mass (BM) supplied by partners ACCUREC (ACC) and TES.

The BM provided by ACC consists of graphite, as well as transition metals such as nickel (Ni), manganese (Mn), and cobalt (Co), along with their respective oxides and impurities like copper (Cu), iron (Fe) and few fluorinated compounds. Li is present in the form of lithium carbonate (Li₂CO₃), lithium fluoride (LiF) and lithium aluminium oxide (LiAlO₂). However, breaking off lithium aluminium oxide to a soluble Li-salt and removing fluoride contamination proved to be challenging.

Previous work reported the simultaneous incorporation of fluoride ions and decomposition of LiAlO₂ using an excess of calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)₂) at elevated temperatures.  More recent developments of the processes show improvement, especially decreasing considerably the amount of of Ca(OH)₂ , while achieving a Li extraction of 87 %. Instead of heating the suspension, it is possible to initiate the reaction by liquid-assisted grinding in a planetary mill. The results show LiAlO₂ is decomposed. However, the fluoride content is not efficiently removed.

In the BM supplied by the partner TES, most Li is present as lithium transition metal oxides (LiTMO) and a small amount of LiF. To enable Li extraction, this BM was reduced by reactive milling in Task 4.4 – Reactive milling for the production of metallic black mass (MBM). The obtained MBM consists of graphite, the metallic composite, lithium oxide and the oxidised reducing agent, along with some impurities like Fe and fluorinated compounds.

After investigating aluminium (Al) and calcium (Ca) in the previous steps, researchers at KIT performed tests to assess Li extraction using a magnesium (Mg) system, which presents various advantages, namely: avoiding, on one hand, the formation of Li salts with bad solubility, and relying on the other hand on insolubility of Mg in the high pH aqueous solution.

After aqueous extraction, researchers obtained a mixture of Li₂CO₃ and LiF. In the upcoming months, this mixture will be purified to a battery-grade material.

Authors: CHA and PNO

An important component of a Li-ion battery (LiB), the electrolyte has a crucial role in the cell performance. The nonaqueous electrolyte is a multicomponent system consisting of a conductive salt, mainly LiPF₆ (Lithium hexafluorophosphate – inorganic component), organic carbonate solvents and additives.

Numerous research initiatives are dedicated to the design of the electrolyte composition, aiming to optimized performance, increased safety, lifetime and streamlined costs. However, once a LiB reaches its end-of-life (EoL) stages, the electrolyte receives less attention in the favour of the valuable metals that can be recycled from the cathode: Li, Co, Mn, Ni, Al, Cu. Moreover, due to its volatility, toxicity and high flammability, the electrolyte recycling is less studied. When ignored, the spent electrolyte reacts with water to form fluoride, leading to its uncontrolled decomposition and/or evaporation, and thus generating an imminent environmental risk. Due to its composition that includes organic solvents, the presence of residual electrolyte in the black mass is considered hazardous, and it is often a reason hampering the recycling process.

Researchers at Chalmers University (CHA) ) developed a sub- and supercritical carbon dioxide (sc-CO₂) extraction process to selectively recover the electrolyte from spent LiBs. Sc-CO₂ extraction technologies are already widely employed in the food, beverage, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industry. In a nutshell, sc-CO₂ forms when CO₂ surpasses its critical point at 31°C and 73.8 bar pressure. In this so-called supercritical state, CO₂ demonstrates optimal mass-transfer characteristics and can be fine-tuned to alter its physicochemical characteristics by adjusting pressure and/or temperature. However, CO2 proves ineffective as a solvent for high molecular weight polymers and highly polar ionic compounds. However, the addition of a co-solvent or a modifier can significantly improve the solubility properties of sc-CO₂, making this alternative a suitable process to selectively extract LiPF₆ after solvent removal.

Researchers at CHA investigated different process parameters (pressure, temperature, extraction times) to understand their impact on the extraction behavior of different electrolyte solvents such as ethylene carbonate. Their analysis included both qualitative and quantitative results indicating the composition and the purity. Simultaneously, the research also monitored the process exhaust stream for potential formation of LiPF₆ decomposition products. The findings showed that that the non-polar electrolyte solvents like dimethyl carbonate, diethyl carbonate, and ethyl methyl carbonate were successfully extracted using low-density CO₂. The more polar electrolyte components such as ethylene carbonate and propylene carbonate were stepwise extracted by gradually increasing the system’s pressure. The developed technology is a game changer not only for electrolyte recycling but also for increased workplace and transportation safety due to removal of the flammable and hazardous substances from battery black mass. The simplicity of the processing design is an additional advantage of the technology.

More information

© Photo credit: Adobe

The modified Black Mass (BM) obtained in Task 4.4 – Reactive milling for the production of metallic black mass (MBM), as well as the BM supplied by partner ACCUREC (ACC) were leached under different conditions to extract lithium (Li) salt.

The BM provided by ACC consists of graphite, as well as transition metals such as nickel (Ni), manganese (Mn), cobalt (Co), along with their respective oxides and impurities – copper (Cu), iron (Fe), and few fluorinated compounds. Li is present in the form of lithium carbonate [Li₂CO₃] and lithium aluminium oxide [LiAlO₂ ]. However, breaking off LiAlO₂ to a soluble Li-salt and removing fluoride contamination is a challenging process. To overcome this, the BM was heated with calcium hydroxide in deionised water for one hour and then filtered.

Illustrated in the next figure, LiAlO₂ decomposes during heating and transforms into insoluble calcium aluminium hydroxide. Dissolved fluoride anions are caught by Ca²⁺ ions and precipitate as calcium fluoride. The soluble part only contains Li- and Ca-salts. The latter can be transformed into calcium carbonate and removed with a second filtration step.

The second BM from partner TES, obtained after ball milling, consists of graphite, the metallic composite, lithium oxide and the oxidized reducing agent, along with some impurities like Fe and fluorinated compounds.

Lithium extraction after ball milling

In the aluminium system, the extraction of lithium salt poses certain challenges. Due to the tendency of residual aluminium powder to ignite when in contact with air, this requires cautious handling. During milling lithium aluminium oxide is formed, and in the basic solution, a significant amount of aluminium hydroxide dissolves and reacts with lithium hydroxide and CO₂, resulting in the formation of a poorly soluble compound called LACHH. To address this problem, the suspension is heated to 90°C to reinforce the reaction between aluminium hydroxide and lithium hydroxide. The LACHH formed can be decomposed at 350°C into insoluble aluminium oxide and soluble lithium carbonate, which can be separated through filtration.

Lithium extraction in the calcium system, on the other hand, is a relatively straightforward process. The milled powder shows low reactivity towards both oxygen and water. Scientists successfully extracted 98% of lithium from the black mass; however, calcium hydroxide was also dissolved in the process. Subsequent purification steps led to the isolation of lithium carbonate with a purity of 93% in a yield of 75%. The main impurities are shown in the figure displayed below.

In the upcoming months, researchers will work to improve the leaching conditions towards a lower reagent and water consumption, while obtaining a higher purity of resulting lithium salt and lower lithium loses during purification steps.

 

During the second semester, researchers from KIT further studied and improved the conditions for the mechanochemical transformation of Black Mass (BM). With the BM supplied by ACC is already in a reduced state, the focus now shifts towards reducing the BM provided by partner TES.

This BM consists mostly of nickel-manganese-cobalt (NMC) cathode material and graphite, and it was found to cause a longer reaction time. It is expected that the graphite exfoliates during milling and creates thin protective layers around NMC particles and the reducing agent, slowing down the reaction kinetics.

Using variations of milling parameters like ball-to-sample ratio or the type and amount of reducing agent, researchers optimised the process towards the fastest kinetics. During the investigation, no intermediate reduction to transition metal oxides in lower oxidation states was observed. However, the full reduction of the respective part to the metallic composite occurred.

The operation took place in a shaker mill, and it requested an excess of 3.3 equivalents of Aluminium (Al) towards NMC was required to attain a complete reduction within a reasonable time. This transformation was accompanied by the formation of aluminium carbide and the presence of residual fine aluminium powder which caused a  self-ignition hazard when the milled powder came into contact with air.

In contrast, when using calcium as a reactive agent, researchers observed a fast reaction but they also reported a strong dependency of reaction kinetics on calcium size. The hazard of self-ignition when exposed to air was limited in this case by using stoichiometric amounts.

In addition, the research team has been conducting preliminary experiments for the scale-up process using a planetary mill. It was observed that the choice of the milling type has a significant impact on the reaction kinetics. Attempts to crush calcium pieces proved to be unsuccessful, therefore not initiating any reaction. However, when using aluminium, reactions occurred much faster.

In the months ahead, the research team working in WP4 will continue to investigate the milling parameters for the planetary mill.

Find out more information about the activities developed in WP4 in the article Reactive milling for the production of metallic black mass (MBM) – Rhinoceros project (rhinoceros-project.eu)

Read more about the black mass leaching operations in the article Materials extraction and direct routes for the synthesis of electrode materials: Recovery of Lithium as battery grade materials

Focusing on mechanochemical (MC) processing, the chemical transformation of the black masses (BMs) supplied by partners ACCUREC and TES, is planned to be carried out within Work package 4. 

Before MC processing, the black masses were analysed using a combination of different analytical techniques. Both quantitative and qualitative analysis were undertaken to determine the Lithium and transition metals yield of the developing recycling process. 

Using different reducing agents such as Al, Ca, and their mixtures, researchers carried out preliminary investigations of the MC processing of BMs. Within this task, different aspects, such as the role of the ball milling conditions, the ball milling time, presence of other nonreactive components, and nature of the reducing material were investigated. The analysis led to the conclusion that the kinetics of the MC-induced reduction reaction is sensitive to multiple processing parameters, as shown in the featured image: 

The upcoming research will focus on improving the reduction reaction kinetics and eliminating the possible safety hazards of fine powder materials. Once finalised, this work will determine the optimal ball milling conditions to be scaled up. 

Recovery of Lithium as battery grade materials

The process described in Task 4.4 leads to the chemical transformation of the black masses (BMs) into ferromagnetic Co-, Ni- and Mn-containing products, which will be separated from other by-products. Lithium will be extracted from the rest of the solid products in the subsequent aqueous leaching process to be further transformed into battery-grade lithium carbonate (Li₂CO₃) salt. 

Within the M1-M6 period, aqueous leaching of the ball-milled samples using Al and Ca as reducing agents (RA) was carried out. At a preliminary stage of investigations, researchers noticed the resulted Li₂CO₃ materials presented small amount of impurities. 

To increase the yield of lithium recycling, in the upcoming period, the research work will target the improvement of the leaching conditions and the purification process.  

TECNALIA [TEC] has actively undertaken both the coordination tasks and the experimental activities that correspond to the solvometallurgical treatment of the received black masses. Firstly, the coordination of the project started with the preparation of the kick-off meeting, in which the entire Consortium assembled in San Sebastián (Basque Country – Spain) and comprises administration and management to ensure an efficient development of RHINOCEROS project. 

Also, the experimental section concerning the critical materials extraction from the received black masses from spent batteries started out after receiving the samples from partners ACCUREC [ACC] and KIT.  

After characterisation, TEC performed a first round of tests to these samples using a solvometallurgical route and assessing pre-treatment effect on the process. In parallel, State of Art is analysed for different relevant solvometallurgical systems aiming lithium recovery. New batches of experiments will be performed for process optimisation and new tests will also be performed when further black mass samples are received.